Best Running Watches in 2017

After researching over 50 watches, we’ve come up with the best running watches available in 2017. Almost all of these are GPS watches – these have become the go-to watch for runners the past ten years. But for all you runners who just want times and splits, we’ve included a couple chrono watches as well.

The majority of watches on our list are Garmins. Garmin has far surpassed other GPS watch brands in features, ease-of-use, and external accessories. It’s not surprising Garmin dominates the running watch market.

The watches we looked at come in a range of prices and styles. The most basic track time and lap splits as well as speed/pace and distance for GPS models. And many track additional data to give you more feedback during a run and to help analyze workouts afterwards. Some include activity trackers (step counters) and alert notifications from your phone.

Criteria for the Best Running Watches in 2017

In deciding on the best running watches, we looked for certain features and functionality that we felt would be most beneficial to runners. While most watches can be used for running, some place more of an emphasis on triathletes, hikers, paddlers, and skiers. For this list, we are focusing specifically on running.

Physically, we prefered watches that are lightweight with a clear, easy-to-read screen. Battery-life is important. We want enough power to get through several runs without a recharge. And we liked watches that made it easy to upload runs to a computer or phone.

More than just providing time and pace, we liked watches that made it a little easier to get through different types of runs. Some watches had interval timers that gave audible alerts at pre-set time intervals (great for doing a run/walk program or timed speed work). Other watches allowed even more programmable workouts like distance-based intervals and fully customized workouts.

Simplicity and easy controls were taken into account. Sometimes you just want to go for a run. And if you are spending time setting up your watch, adjusting the data screens, or just trying to get the watch to work – that’s a downside to us.

We also examined the ecosystem built for tracking your runs post-workout. Once you’ve gathered all this great data with your watch, the way to upload and view should be simply and easy to read.

We didn’t put too much weight on accuracy for the GPS watches. Accuracy is incredible variable in terms of overall distance and especially real-time pace. Factors including tree and cloud cover, nearby buildings, and terrain all play a role in GPS accuracy. And with current GPS technology, all the watches we cover in this list are very accurate over the long haul.

With that being said (drum roll, please), here are our top running watches of 2017….

All-around winner

Garmin Forerunner 235

The Forerunner 235 hits the sweet spot for us with a mix of great features, simple design, a reasonable price, and enough extra functions to make our runs more fun without feature-overload. Plus it comes with wrist-based heart rate (see the Forerunner 230 below for a non-heart rate option) and good battery-life.

With a nice, big screen and readable display, the Forerunner 235 is easy to view during a run. It also has a built-in accelerometer, so it can track runs both outside and indoors on a treadmill. It doubles as an activity tracker to count steps, set daily step goals, and monitor sleep. Post-run, workouts can be uploaded wirelessly to a smartphone where a variety of data including pace, distance, elevation, and cadence can be analyzed .

For training, the Forerunner 235 supports interval workouts for distance and time (including a run/walk timer) as well as customized, advanced workouts. Training plans can even be downloaded directly onto the watch.

The Forerunner 235 isn’t the cheapest option out there (**editor’s note: the Forerunner 235 price dropped by $30 effective Nov 2017**). But it sits in the middle, price-wise, of most GPS watches and has enough features to justify the higher price.

Check Price on Amazon

Best Discontinued GPS Watch

Garmin Forerunner 230

For quite a bit less money, the Forerunner 230 is nearly identical the 235. The only feature missing is wrist-based heart rate. You’ll need a chest-strap if you want to monitor heart rate.

Otherwise, the watches are exactly the same in size, features, and customization. Even better, the 230 has been discontinued by Garmin so it often be found at 20-25% off the original $250 cost.

Check Price on Amazon



Best Top of the Line Watch

Garmin Forerunner 735XT

Originally released as a triathlon watch (see our full review of triathlon watches here), the Forerunner 735XT is also the best running watch in 2017. It tracks huge amounts of data and provides a ton of extra information and training aids when out on a run. Garmin has recently positioned the 735XT as their replacement to the Forerunner 630, their prior top-end running watch, by dropping the price $50 in mid-2017.

(**editor’s note: the Forerunner 735XT price dropped by $50 effective Nov 2017**)

For runners, the watch tracks time/pace/distance and, like Garmin’s other high-end watches, has wrist heart rate monitoring. It’s thin and lightweight with a large, color display like the Forerunner 235. Custom workouts and intervals can be programmed into the watch to help with speed work, hill repeats, and other multi-step runs.

What makes the 735XT better than the Forerunner 235 are the various metrics it tracks related to running form. These include cadence, vertical oscillation (i.e. how much you “bounce” running), and ground contact. Some of these require you to wear Garmin’s chest heart rate monitor, but they are nice features if you are interested in improving your running form.

The Forerunner 735XT also has Garmin’s virtual runner features. These make it fun to run at a specific pace and compare how you are doing vs. prior runs (see our full article about virtual runner here).

Finally, the battery is improved over the Forerunner 235 (14 hours GPS mode vs. 11 hours) and there are some fun extras like live Strava segments and bread-crumb route navigation.

Check Price on Amazon

Best Basic GPS Watch with Wrist Heart Rate

Garmin Forerunner 35

This watch just works. Simple, easy-to-use, nice design, and readable screen. The Forerunner 35 tracks basic info with the addition of wrist-based heart rate. It’s currently our second favorite running watch.

It’s not the cheapest watch out there in this category – but you always pay a slightly higher premium for a Garmin. With that, you get Garmin’s system for uploading/analyzing runs, great tech support if things go wrong, and the accuracy and straight-up great functionality that Garmin provides.

Beyond the basics, Garmin threw in a few additional features like interval workouts, activity tracking, and smartphone notifications into the watch. There are multiple color options but the bands can’t be swapped out. It can also track treadmill workouts.

This is the watch to get if you want an uncomplicated watch with wrist heart rate.

Check Price on Amazon

Best Budget GPS Watch with Wrist Heart Rate

Polar M200

If you want a basic GPS watch with wrist heart rate for a better price than the Forerunner 35 ($50 less at the time of publication), the Polar M200 is your best option.

Like the Forerunner 35, it has wrist heart rate with basic GPS functions. It’s simple and easy to use. And because it’s from Polar, there are additional metrics Polar provides to analyze training based on heart rate. Smartphone notification alerts also appear on the watch.

The downside is that the display is pretty small and hard to read. Not great for running, especially when trying to read those notifications.

It can also be used for activity tracking, but one thing we didn’t like is the lack of 24/7 heart rate monitoring. This is something Garmin provides on the Forerunner 35.

Additional watch bands can be purchased, too, if you want to swap out the strap for another color.

Ultimately, the M200 is a nice watch if you want to save a little cash next to the Forerunner 35. These watches are pretty similar except for the harder-to-read display on the M200 and the lack of Garmin’s tech support and overall ecosystem.

Check Price on Amazon


Best Basic GPS without Heart Rate

Garmin Forerunner 25

If you want a basic GPS watch without wrist heart rate, then the Forerunner 25 is your best option. This is Garmin’s cheapest watch (now off MSRP, so it costs less than its original $140 price) and offers basic GPS functions with some nice add-on features.

Like all of Garmin’s watches, it tracks steps, sets daily goals, and monitors sleep. Bluetooth syncing provides smartphone notifications and wireless uploads to a phone. The watch is easy to use and the screen is a decent size and readable.

Battery-life is pretty good for a watch at this price (8-10 hours in GPS) mode and it comes in a few different color options.

Check Price on Amazon

Best Budget GPS Watch

TomTom Runner

The TomTom Runner keeps it simple: time/pace/distance. Simple, one-button design. Easy-to-read screen. Interval workouts can be programmed. And it’s got a nice battery-life of 10 hours in GPS mode.

Even better, the TomTom Runner retails for about $100; however, you can find it for 20%-40% less on Amazon.

If you want to see our full list of the best budget GPS watches, read this article.

Check Price on Amazon


Best GPS Watch with Music

TomTom Spark 3 Music + Headphones

We already like the TomTom Runner as one of our top budget GPS watches. The new Spark 3 Music + Headphones has basic GPS features found on the Runner plus music storage and playback. It even comes with bluetooth headphones that pair with the watch. No longer do you need to bring a phone to listen to music while you run.

We also like that the Spark 3 has programmable intervals for improved training. You can even race against yourself from a past run.

Like many of the GPS watches on the market, this one will count steps and monitor sleep. It’s got a decent battery (11 hours in GPS mode) and wirelessly syncs runs to a phone. For indoor runs, it tracks pace and distance based on cadence.

The TomTom Spark 3 isn’t the most advanced or cheapest watch out there. But it’s one of the few that can store music. Combined with a simple user interface, it’s our best choice for running with music.

Check Price on Amazon

Best Non-GPS Watch

Timex Ironman Sleek 150

A nice, basic watch. Great if you’re only interested in a timer with plenty of memory for lap splits. The screen is big, it runs on a plain watch battery, so recharging isn’t necessary. The Sleek 150 has a touch-screen, requiring only a tap on the watch face to mark a lap.

The Sleek 150 is water-resistant to 100m and has enough memory for 5 workouts. Additionally, it has some nice timing features that can be set to remind you when to drink and eat (based on timed intervals). Timed intervals can also be programmed if you are doing a specific timed speed workout.

Check Price on Amazon



Best Budget Non-GPS Watch

Timex Ironman Sleek 50

A classic. Feather-light, slim. When you want to feel free and only need to know your time and splits, the Ironman Sleek 50 fits the bill. It’s a water-resistant stop-watch with enough memory for 50 laps. This is watch we like for races or any workout where you don’t need to know your distance or real-time pace.

Besides a stopwatch, the Ironman Sleek 50 has a countdown timer and alarm settings. It’s INDIGLO light makes it easy to read in low-light conditions. Best of all, it’s a plain, old watch so no need to worry about charging the battery.

Check Price on Amazon


No Comments

    Leave a reply